What’s the new story of us? | Mathieu Lefevre
Transcription Whisper (large-v3), avec identification des locuteurs. À recouper avec la source d'origine.
Analyse automatique
Générée par IA — peut contenir des erreurs. Méthodologie
Chapitres
Répartition du ton (temps de parole politique)
Propositif 95 %Attaque 3 %Défensif 2 %
Affirmations vérifiables (citations exactes)
- 0:54PrésentateurFait
« Those people up there are literally dumping their shit on us down here. »
- 0:54PrésentateurFait
« I have to take a pressure hose and clean my house once in a while. »
- 3:55PrésentateurFait
« It appears to me that we are facing very large collective challenges. »
- 5:14PrésentateurFait
« Climate change is the obvious one. »
- 10:02PrésentateurFait
« People actually agree on quite a lot. »
- 10:48PrésentateurFait
« Most Americans have a very distorted understanding of what people think on the other side of the political divide. »
Temps de parole
- Présentateur89 %
- ?11 %
≈ 121,5 interruptions / 10 min (chevauchements et interjections détectés).
Modèle mistral-small-latest · prompt v1 · les citations sont vérifiées mot pour mot dans le transcript ; le taux de réponse directe est calculé à partir des verdicts question par question. Aucun label idéologique n'est produit.
A
few months ago,
I
sat in the back
of
a local function room in a small town in rural France.
It
was a rainy Tuesday night,
and
the room was packed.
It
was the local meeting of the yellow vests, the gilets jaunes, which you have heard of.
People
were really fired up.
One
man stood up and started talking about people up there, people who take airplanes.
He
was talking about the elites, of course. Those people up there, he said, those people up there are literally dumping their shit on us down here.
I
have to take a pressure hose and clean my house once in a while.
This
town I was in
was
about 100 kilometers south of Orly Airport, and it was in the flight path to the airport, and apparently,
I
didn't know this,
because
once in a while airplanes have to dump kerosene before they land.
That
story really struck with me, because I think it says volumes about how large portions of the population, particularly in Western democracies but really everywhere, feel today.
They
feel left behind. They feel invisible. They feel unheard.
It
also says a lot about how people view the world.
People
view the world as an us versus them.
And
if you read the news, it's not just the yellow vest in France, obviously. It's in Chile. It's in Beirut. It's in Barcelona.
It's
a global problem.
So, how
did we get here?
Even
a few years ago, certainly to me, it seemed unthinkable that
the
very basic principles, the very foundational values that certainly I adhere to, would be called into question like this.
Think
back to a time before Donald Trump.
It's
hard to do.
Think
back to a time before Brexit. Also hard to do. Before the rise of the AFD.
It
was unthinkable, then, that basic values would be called into question. Things like democracy,
the
rule of law,
a
free press,
not
pointing fingers at the most vulnerable people in our societies.
Even
basic things like hearing each other out, letting
people
finish their sentence before you start yelling on Twitter all the time.
It
feels to me like those things are being threatened, and certainly threatened more than they've ever been in my lifetime.
And in
a way, it's like we're living a bad dream.
It's
like that period in history that people 40 years from now will refer to and say that's when it started.
It
kind of feels like the slow start of a civil war.
And
for me personally, it brings back bad memories, a sort of PTSD.
I
spent five years working in places like Afghanistan and Syria and Lebanon,
and
I know what it's like when people start to turn on one another, when societies start to tear apart.
Now,
of course, I'm not suggesting that Lisbon is about to become Libya. That would be ridiculous, of course.
But
I think it would be equally foolish
not
to be worried about the way things are going.
And
I am worried, if I'm honest, about the path we are taking, and I'm very preoccupied by what we here in this room could do about it.
Aren't
you?
So then
people will legitimately ask, well, is this new? Haven't we been here before?
And
yes, we have been here before.
We
have faced great times of polarization and social tension and social division. Of course we have. And I think we will again.
I'm
an optimist.
But
one thing that I think is new today, and perhaps like never before, is that it appears to me that we are facing very large collective challenges. collective challenges that present an existential threat to the entire human race.
Now,
I am not an AI expert, and there are many in this room. But it seems to me like AI is a good example.
It's
one of the greatest challenges of our time, without a doubt.
It
seems to me to present great opportunities to cure diseases and do the hard work that we won't need to do.
But
it also presents enormous risks. Dealing with AI is a complex matter. It has to be addressed globally.
But
it's really hard to focus on this, on these issues that require coordination and common ground, when the President of the United States is screaming in all caps on Twitter all the time,
and
when his opponents are screaming back even louder.
While
our house, not this house, but the global house, is so distracted and divided,
it
seems to me, for example, that tech companies are not getting the kind of scrutiny that they should be getting on things like AI.
We
simply will not be able to deal with these common challenges, unless, and of course, there are many more, not just AI. Climate change is the obvious one. We won't be able to deal with these problems unless we can come together, unless we can turn down the volume and focus on what we have in common, including our common challenges, and not just on our differences.
So
it feels very urgent to me to understand what's going on.
In
2016, I co-founded an organization called More in Common with this amazing group of people. Basically, what we do is we try to understand what divides us, what is tearing our societies apart, and we focus most intently on Western democracies.
And
then what we do is we try to come up with the stories, the narratives, the partnerships, the messages that have the potential to bring us together again.
When
we set off on this journey, we had three instincts.
The
first instinct was that to explain what was going on, to explain polarization and social division, we had to look under the hood of people's opinions.
We
needed to focus on that sort of bottom of the iceberg stuff, into people's core values, their emotions. So we thought that this was much more about psychology than about policy.
Our
second instinct was that we needed more nuance and complexity. The tendency to simplify just wasn't explaining what was going on.
and
the third was that equipped with a richer, more complex and nuanced lens, we would see the world in a different way, possibly more daunting but also more hopeful.
So
we dove into the literature on social sciences and social psychology and we asked tens of thousands of people all over the world what they think about belonging,
what
they think about fear, how they relate to their neighbors.
and
we then grouped these people according to this hidden architecture, their core values. We did not group people in using traditional indicators like race or income or education.
And
here's what this looks like. So in the United States, we ran a project that was called Hidden Tribes.
And
basically what we found were seven different groups of people that corresponded to their different hidden infrastructure, that hidden architecture of value.
A
lot of what you hear in the United States, the story that we all hear in the United States, is a story of a 50-50 country, a country that can't agree on anything. It's Fox versus MSNBC,
it's
rural versus urban, it's impeachers versus trumpers, it's red versus blue.
But
actually what we found is that when you apply this more complex lens, we got a more complex picture, one that looks both daunting in some ways but opens up lots of areas of compromise.
And
we did not pull our punches. We asked all the hard questions about Black Lives Matter, about immigration, about Me Too. And here's
an
example of the picture this gives us. So if you ask Americans about immigration, basically is it a good or a bad thing, or about sexual harassment, if you use a traditional lens, you do in fact get a 50-50 country. On immigration, it's 51-49.
But
if you apply a more complex lens, you get a much richer picture.
This
work got a lot of attention in the media in the United States. And the reason I'm showing you this, this is David Brooks' column about this work in the New York Times, and the reason I'm showing you this is just to show that I am not alone, and that much smarter people than I are also worrying about the next civil war.
A
few days ago, we published a study on Germany. And here too, we grouped people according to their hidden infrastructure, their hidden architecture of values. And we found something very interesting, that there was an invisible third in society, that traditional studies weren't capturing, weren't capturing their insights.
And
here too, if you ask the tough questions, for example, about how Germans think about the crimes of the past, you get a much richer picture, and one that opens up a lot of areas of compromise. Now, what led me to this work is genuine concern, genuine concern about the next civil war. But also, I'm an optimist, and I think most of you in this room are too.
And
the good news is that our research actually gave us many reasons to be hopeful.
So
I'll just give you three quick examples.
The
first one is that people actually agree on quite a lot. These are some examples from the US, from France, and from Germany. But overall, we see agreement on two things. One, about three-quarters of the people in these countries think that the state of polarization and division has never been worse.
But
the second thing is that roughly the same proportion of people, about three-quarters of the people, think that we must and can get through this together.
The
second reason to believe in this is that
I
think this is largely a matter of perception. If people understood one another better, then perhaps they might see that they have a lot more in common than what they think.
So
we ran a project in the United States called the Perception Gap,
where
we found that most Americans have a very distorted understanding of what people think
on
the other side of the political divide.
So
here you see the gap between Democrats and Republicans on the question of immigration and racism, versus what Republicans actually think.
And
we ran this, obviously, the other way around,
and
on a whole bunch of issues. And actually, the perception gap is immense.
And
I think that's a reason to be hopeful.
But
most of all,
the
reason to be optimistic come from things that can't be captured in a graph.
It's
the stories of people who we've met, the hundreds and hundreds of people who we've met in small towns and big cities all over the world.
And
I'm really struck by one thing, is how much people want to be together.
People
are yearning for a sense of belonging.
The
yellow vest that I started with,
I
don't agree with this movement, and I certainly don't agree with the use of violence. But I was so struck,
spending
a lot of time with them recently, by how they wanted to be together. These are people who are lonely and isolated because of the kind of work they do, or the kind of family situation they're in. And they put on that high-visibility jacket, and you know what?
They're
seen.
They
feel together.
They
have this joy of rallying under this bright yellow banner.
This is
a picture from an event that we helped organize called the Great Get-Together. Millions of people all across the United Kingdom got together to celebrate what they had in common. Very British things. Tea. Cake. Football.
And
dozens and dozens and dozens reported just how nice it was to be with their neighbors,
just
how nice it was to meet a stranger who wasn't like them.
So, in
closing, I'd like to ask for your help.
Why
do I need you, the members of this amazing house?
In
the 17th and 18th century,
men
and women in Europe and in places like Massachusetts were fed up with the status quo,
and
they set off into the unknown, many times into the Western United States.
And
they set off to set up utopian communities, places with names like Oneida and the Shakers and New Jerusalem and the Fourierist phalanxes.
Not
all of these projects were a success, but I really liked learning about them and reading about them because they did one thing that was so important.
They
helped to reinvent what it is to have a good life.
They
made dreaming great again.
And
I think this house,
I
really do, I think of you in this house as the new utopians,
because
we need you badly.
I
think we all need to fall in love with the future again.
We've
seen it in our research.
In
all kinds of settings, people are yearning for a new story,
a
big, beautiful, new story.
A
story that tells a story of a bigger us,
that
tells of a new meaning of what it is to belong,
that
tells a story of what it is to be in a relationship with one another,
that
tells a story of what our relationship to the earth
and
to nature should be.
not
the narrow nativist us versus them story, which is really dominating the airwaves today,
but
a big, and yes, a beautiful story. Finding that story
is
the quest of our time,
and
I think you all here in this house have an important role to play
to
lead us to the promised land,
because
I fear
that
it is the next civil war, or us here in this house, the new utopians.
Thank
you.