(Audiobook) The Lower Registers - André Forget (Earth World Collaborative)
Transcription Whisper (large-v3), avec identification des locuteurs. À recouper avec la source d'origine.
Analyse automatique
Générée par IA — peut contenir des erreurs. Méthodologie
Chapitres
Répartition du ton (temps de parole politique)
Propositif 50 %Attaque 7 %Défensif 14 %
Affirmations vérifiables (citations exactes)
- 1:45InvitéChiffre
« The first in this country, the largest in the world. »
- 4:05InvitéFait
« Print references to underwater organs are almost non-existent before the 19th century. »
- 5:13InvitéFait
« The first indisputable reference to an underwater organ comes with the publication of Giovanni Bonavista's Catalogue of Musical Instruments New and Proposed in 1833. »
- 7:50InvitéFait
« On August 15, 1993, an unknown aquatic engineer, architect, and amateur organist named Kenji Saito announced that he had completed his Senritsu. »
- 30:19InvitéFait
« Nova Scotia was like no other place on Earth, which is why it was the perfect place to build the largest organ, sorry, yes, hydro-organon, the world had ever seen. »
Temps de parole
- Invité86 %
- ?14 %
≈ 181,2 interruptions / 10 min (chevauchements et interjections détectés).
Modèle mistral-small-latest · prompt v1 · les citations sont vérifiées mot pour mot dans le transcript ; le taux de réponse directe est calculé à partir des verdicts question par question. Aucun label idéologique n'est produit.
The
Lower Registers
I
arrived in the city
on
a Tuesday afternoon,
under
low clouds.
I
walked out of the train station, and the statues in the park,
the
grey faces,
the
homeless people shuffling beneath the trees,
seemed
to belong to another time.
My
hotel was up the hill, across from the Citadel,
but
I followed the station road twisting down to Bishop's Wharf.
I'd
seen the water from the window of the train as we came in along the port. Grey, like the weather.
Everything
on the waterfront was new and clean but the water itself.
I
smoked a cigarette and threw the butt into the filthy scrim licking the wooden piles.
The
smell of salt and kelp and dead things clung to the pier.
I
was completely alone.
On
the far shore I could see the holding tanks and cooling towers of the derelict refinery, flat and ugly against the horizon.
The
pilot flame of the flare stack extinguished.
In
between, the sleek back of a small island rising from the water,
and
in the distance another, larger one.
But
it was the harbour I was interested in.
One
of the deepest in the Maritimes.
For
years it had been the place where Europeans stepped out of their histories to become happy provincial Canadians.
And
now,
below
its untroubled surface,
a
strange machine was being built.
The
first in this country,
the
largest in the world.
Yet
there was no evidence of it at all.
It
started to rain, and I walked up to my hotel.
The
lobby was sepulchral.
A
long, washed-out man standing behind the front desk
pushed
his glasses up his nose and asked if he could help me.
He
didn't look like he wanted to.
I
told him my name, and he consulted his computer screen.
He
began fussing about, looking for the plastic keycard.
Business? He
said,
and
I realized he was asking why I had come.
I
suppose.
You
suppose?
I'm
writing a piece about the organ.
Oh,
that.
He
gave me a look.
What
a stupid idea. Typically stupid.
The
city's always coming up with these stupid ideas. It's because of the money.
They
keep thinking one of these stupid ideas is going to make a pile of money for the city.
It
never occurs to them to invest in something that might actually feed some folks, but
there's
always a handout for some half-wit professor with a bonkers idea that will really put Halifax on the map.
You
heard about the refinery?
Turning
it into a terminal for cruise ships.
See,
it'll boost the local economy. Bring in those American dollars.
As
if someone on a goddamn cruise is going to stay at my hotel.
I
tried to look sympathetic.
He
hadn't handed over my key yet.
Perhaps
with the organ it will be different,
I
said.
The
proprietor nodded.
There
was a twitch around his left eye that made it look like he was winking. Listen,
I'm
United Church myself, so it's not like I'm against organs as such.
Used
to love listening to my grand play, the one they had up at St. Matthew's.
Beautiful
sound, especially with those old hymns. You know, holy, holy, holy. Oh God, our help in ages past.
Get
all choked up just thinking about it.
They
took it out when the young minister decided to get rid of the hymns and play everything on his guitar.
Real
asshole.
No
sense for the tradition.
I'm
telling you this only so as you know I'm what you might call sympathetic to the organ, really.
What
I don't understand is, if they were going to build the biggest organ in the world,
why
did they decide to put it at the bottom of the harbor?
However, the
origins of hydro-organonology are deeply contested.
references to underwater organs are almost non-existent before the 19th century,
but
this has not stopped some of the more enthusiastic hydro-organonologists from arguing
that
hydro-organons are nearly as old as their more famous terrestrial counterparts. Archaeological evidence suggests a hydro-organon may have been among the many pleasures Tiberius arranged built as part of his Villa Chovus on Capri,
though
it is so scant,
and
the possibility so unlikely given the villa's high altitude,
that
most scholars view it with extreme suspicion.
A
more substantive find was discovered off the coast of Spain in 1977, consisting of several large pipes and a wind chest dating from the 15th century.
But
given that the remains are a mere kilometer from the site of a galleon known to have been wrecked en route from Genoa,
the
argument that it is a primitive hydro-organon,
and
not simply the scattered parts of a conventional organ, rather stretches credulity.
Most
scholars agree that the first indisputable reference to an underwater organ comes with the publication of Giovanni Bonavista's Catalogue of Musical Instruments New and Proposed in 1833,
which
includes schema for a rudimentary hydro-organon featuring ten pipes,
and
a bellows operated through an ingenious series of hoses and manual pumps.
While
Bonavista claimed that the hydro-organon was a completely novel instrument,
and
was, in fact, the first to use the term hydro-organon to describe a sub-aqueous organ,
this
claim has been hotly debated. Skeptics point out that Bonavista was hardly scrupulous about offering credit where credit was due,
and
had a tendency to claim authorship for ideas for instruments that had venerable, if usually obscure, theoretical pedigrees. Speculative hydro-organonics became a popular exercise for engineers and organ makers in the decades that followed.
No
less an inventor than Issembard Kingdom Brunel came up with a design for a hydro-organon to be built off the coast of Cornwall,
and
Arthur Schoenberg and Igor Stravinsky are both reputed to have written works for the theoretical instrument,
though
autographs are yet to be found of either.
It
was after the Second World War that hydro-organonology really came into its own as a discipline.
During
the post-war construction boom,
several
of the more experimental architects placed miniature, non-functional hydro-organons in artificial ponds, marine parks, waterfalls, etc.
John
Cage's journals are filled with references to the instrument,
and
he made several attempts in the 60s and 70s to raise funds to build a test hydro-organon
off
a rocky stretch of coastline near Eureka, California.
It
has been argued,
most
notably by Dr. Susan Shaw,
the
maverick director of Winnipeg's new music festival during its turbulent and anarchic period in the late 1980s,
that
Cage's legendary 433
was
inspired by the paradoxical acoustic possibilities of a subaqueous organ.
Shaw
believed that the piece's famous four and a half minutes of silence
were
a tribute and gesture towards a future
in
which that silence could be filled by the deep tones of a hydro-organon.
She
even theorized that Cage had written a companion piece to 433, consisting of a score exactly four minutes and 33 seconds in length
to
be played on a hydro-organon once it had been invented.
But the
beginning of modern hydro-organonology,
hydro
-organonology as a fully actualized musical discipline, is precisely datable.
On
August 15, 1993,
an
unknown aquatic engineer, architect, and amateur organist named Kenji Saito announced that he had completed his Senritsu,
the
first full-scale,
fully
functional hydro-organon to be built in the modern era,
on
a promontory off the course of Numatsu in Japan's Tsuruga Bay. Overnight, hydro-organonology went from being an armchair science
to
a controversial new form of public art,
one
that united disciplines as diverse as acoustics, oceanography, architecture, and musicology. Saito's masterpiece offered both a concrete example of the challenges of practical hydro-organonics
and
a new way of thinking about the musical
and
musicological possibilities of the instrument.
The
first public performance on the Senritsu featured a program built around Bach's Klavier Ubung III,
with
some of Saito's own improvisations thrown in to show the range of the instrument.
A
recording was made,
but
issues around ownership and copyright have kept it from public release.
Those
who have heard it
note
that it is vastly inferior to the experience of seeing the Senritsu in action.
But
even at this, the first recorded performance of a hydro-organon,
the
audience members were sharply divided as to the nature of what they had witnessed.
Most
found the music itself completely secondary to the spectacle of watching the air jet and bubble out of the great pipes
and
acknowledged that they were at best only able to hear a rich humming sound
with
a few quavering variations as new pipes were opened.
But
others,
a
decided,
though
not insubstantial minority, claimed to have heard a completely breathtaking range of sounds,
not
the sounds of a terrestrial organ,
but
a completely faithful transformation of them,
as
though they were hearing Bach's music performed by whales.
One
account,
from
a professor of Baroque music who had been personally invited by Saito, likened the experience to watching a skilled and inventive translator render Goethe into English.
Over
the course of the late summer and early autumn of 1993,
Saito
brought several diving groups down to view the hydro-organon,
and
word began to spread in avant-garde musical circles and among the more speculative branches of musicology
of
this massive organ
built
into a rock face at the bottom of a Japanese bay.
The
question of what the hydro-organon meant,
having
been completed at a time when the traditional pipe organ seemed little more than an anachronistic holdover from a time when people didn't have electricity and believed in God,
quickly
overshadowed the actual experience of listening to the hydro-organon being played,
except
for those stubborn few who insisted that they had heard something remarkable when the pipes were opened. Musicians and theorists made the pilgrimage to Numatsu because they felt it would be gauche to write about the Senritsu if they hadn't actually heard it.
Some
of them came away utterly changed.
Most
of them managed to get something about it published in Music Perception or Interface.
As
the winter of 1993-94 set in, Saito stopped bringing groups down to the Senritsu, citing the unpredictable weather conditions in Suruga Bay.
He
spent the winter in his cabin on the slopes of Mount Fuji,
where
he could see the restless waters and dream of his hydro-organon.
It
is generally agreed that it was during these months he wrote
what
would stand as his most complete theoretical account of hydro-organonology,
usually
translated in English as the bass note. Saito resumed his tours the next spring to redoubled interest from both the local and international baroque and classical scenes.
He
received letters from Arvo Part, Philip Glass, and Kaijo Sarriaho, and was interviewed by the BBC.
It
was an odd story,
and
people liked its oddness.
This
young Japanese Renaissance man, with a quasi-mystical theory of harmony and a deep love for the music of Johann Sebastian Bach,
had
created an instrument that the professional music world had always imagined to be nothing more than a curiosity.
And
he had made it beautiful.
Some
even believed he had made it sing.
But
Kenji Saito's burgeoning career as the first professional hydro-organologist ended early in the morning of June 18, 1995,
when
his body was found floating off the coast of Nishitsu.
He
was wearing his wetsuit,
and
his mask was off,
though
his oxygen tank was still at 30%.
It
was clear he had drowned.
No
one, however, was ever able to explain why. Saito's tragic death,
and
the simultaneous publication of the English edition of the base note,
provided
the impetus for the first academic conference dedicated to hydro-organology.
Held
in Fuji in early 1996,
it
drew scholars from across the vast range of disciplines connected theoretically to the hydro-organon.
But
by far the most widely attended panels were led by musicologists,
eager
to establish that their own theories of the hydro-organon
had
the greatest explanatory power and revolutionary potential.
The
base note was a fascinating document,
but
it did not lay out any kind of coherent theoretical program. Saito had seemed less interested in explaining what the hydro-organon meant than exploring what it could do,
and
specifically,
what
it could do to Western music. Saito's lens was highly idiosyncratic,
starting
with Psalm 42.7,
Deep
calleth unto deep at the noise of thy waterspouts, all thy waves and thy billows are gone over me. Saito, whose father had been a Presbyterian minister,
set
out in brief an interpretation of the entire Baroque organ canon
as
an exploration of the idea of depth.
Whereas
traditional representations of Christian cosmology imagined the divine as being above, Saito posited that organ music is at its most powerful and its most unique
in
the lower registers.
After
several chapters dedicated to technical digressions on the nature of lower frequencies of sound,
Saito
arrived at what would appear to be the kernel of his argument.
The
divine is most present in the literal, sonic, geographic, and symbolic depths.
God
is the throbbing hum of an inhumanly low frequency,
a
bass note that sustains the universe.
This,
Saito believed, was the true meaning of the old musica universalis.
By
placing an organ,
the
instrument most capable of rendering deep registers, and the western instrument most closely associated with divinity,
in
the literal depths of the ocean,
the
hydroorganon became a nexus of spiritual power. Hydroorganologists who read the bass note fell in love with it immediately,
both
for its technicality and its outrageousness, long and durable academic careers having been forged on far less.
What
quickly came to be considered the mainstream of hydroorganological theory derived less from Saito's text itself,
though
it is generally, and perhaps carefully, acknowledged to be a classic of hydroorganonic theory,
than
with the secondary work of James Whitney and Nicola Finucci,
both
of whom argued that the hydroorganon represented the end and apotheosis of western music.
In
his book, Transmusical Expressionism in the Oral Aquatic,
Critical
Essays on Kenji Saito's Senritsu, Whitney argued that in a world where most musicologists are still trapped in a logocentric obsession with sound as the essential basis for music, hydroorganonics heralded a rupture in its rejection of oral normativity as a basis for the study of music,
one
that liberated musicology from the heteropatriarchal colonialist logic of late capitalism.
What
could be more revolutionary in the history of western music, he argued in the final incendiary essay Sabacqueous Rhapsody,
than
an organ that didn't make any noise?
From
a strictly musicological standpoint, Finucci's thesis followed a similar trajectory.
Starting
with the argument that, with the senritzu, Saito had finally completed the long process of the deconstruction of the western music tradition that began nearly a century earlier with Arthur Schoenberg,
she
garnered significant praise among ecocritics for showing that hydroorganonics also operated as a kind of environmentalist guerrilla aesthetics. Acknowledging that the building of senritzu had caused some environmental damage to its immediate location,
in
order to accommodate the massive wind trunk
and
the pumps bringing air down to fill it, a sizable portion of rock had been blasted away, senritzu ultimately symbolized a more, as it were, harmonious, readers were coyly asked to pardon the pun, relationship between humans and their natural environment.
And
a side effect of having such a valuable tourist attraction in what was still a commercial harbor
meant
local governments had to be more thoughtful about how they disposed of industrial waste.
With
scores of scuba divers descending to witness concerts every day,
an
unprecedented degree of attention was now being paid to water quality and biodiversity in Tsuruga Bay.
Not
everyone, however, was equally taken with the novelty of senritzu,
nor
was it universally understood to be the culmination of musical postmodernity. Johann Schrader argued that the principles underlying senritzu
were
the same that had governed Sestibius of Alexandria's 3rd century BCE Hydraulus,
which
had established the essential blueprint of all future organs and hydroorganons,
air
forced through pipes of varying lengths and sizes
to
create vibrations of specific pitches,
which
were manipulated by opening and closing pipes.
Of
course, there were reactionary voices, too.
Harold
Johnson-Jones, a research chair in musicology at UCLA,
gave
a withering denunciation of Saito's work at the Conference of Musical Aesthetics in Heidelberg in 1997.
In
his opening keynote, Johnson-Jones suggested senritzu had as much artistic merit as the London eye and about the same function.
An
earlier generation of musicologists, he argued,
would
not have been fooled by this kind of stunt.
But
the rise of postmodern theory had had such a corrosive, degrading effect that the once fine minds in his own department were now more interested in pumps and bubbles than the hard historical and theoretical work required to really understand the genius of the great composers.
And
as for the organists sucked in by this nonsense, well, what kind of commitment to craft could there be in playing a Bach chorale prelude if no one could properly hear it?
Where
was the discipline required to master the old instruments and techniques, Johnson-Jones wanted to know?
At
least Picasso could paint like a realist when he wanted to.
These
young hydro-organists had barely mastered their first concerto,
and
already they were trying to reinvent the wheel.
If
these hydro-organologists were so impressed with gimmicks,
what
did they think of the wave organ in San Francisco?
Was
this, too, a bold new aesthetic movement?
The
hydro-organologists present did not take this well,
and
insisted they had as much in common with the wave organ as a Stradivarius did with a plastic guitar.
Over
the years, they would go to great lengths to distance what they believed was the purity of their own art
from
such vulgar popularizations as the cretinous sea organ of Zadar,
with
its inoffensive, repetitive harmonies, smug Croatian street vendors,
and
American tourists gasping at the middle-brow cleverness of it all.
Likewise,
the family-friendly hydrolophones, with their cute, watery burbling, good only for playing irredeemably banal pieces like Pachelbel's Canon in D
and
Jesu Joy of Man's Desiring,
were
mere circus games compared to the grandeur and might of the hydro-organon.
To
everyone's surprise, after being little more than an academic curiosity during the first years of its official existence, hydro-organology became a serious concern.
Local
and national governments began to take an interest in the economic possibilities of the hydro-organon.
Following
his death, Saito's remarkable accomplishments and the tragic, made-for-television arc of his creative life began to attract media attention. Profiles followed in The New Yorker, Der Spiegel, La Figaro, and National Geographic.
Television
crews interviewed his artistic peers, his assistants, his bewildered parents.
They
interviewed Schrader and Fanucci,
whose
expensive words in Ivy League diction cast the enterprise in an excitingly intellectual light.
Attempts
were made, in vain,
to
unmask his famously mysterious financial backers. Famous organists agreed to give performances on Senritsu, and tourists flocked to Suruga Bay to watch them.
There
was still a clear divide among those who witnessed performances on the hydro-organon as to whether they were, in fact, listening to anything.
Those
who said they were, always a minority,
claimed
they simply had a more refined musical sensitivity.
Those
who said they weren't
tended
to assume those who said they were, sonicists, they called themselves,
were
hopeless exaggerators and posers,
the
kind of people who believed they could tell the difference between a Chateauneuf-de-Pap 2002
and
a Chateauneuf-de-Pap 2006.
But
as Senritsu was such an awesome sight to behold, spectators continued to don their wetsuits and descend for the daily performances.
As
for the musicologists,
such
questions generally didn't interest them.
They
settled on whatever accounts best suited the critical narrative they were trying to build around hydro-organonology.
Plenty
of cities have made a tourist industry out of music,
but
whereas the restaurants and hotels of Salzburg had benefited from the Mozart festivals, Numatsu, the nearest town to Senritsu,
also
raked in cash from the rental of scuba gear, the chartering of boats,
and
tours of the various sites associated with the secretive Saito's life.
Other
coastal cities realized that there was a substantial economic incentive for backing similar projects in their own jurisdictions.
Given
the fact that, in the grand scheme of things, a working hydro-organon cost significantly less than a new concert hall,
and
provided a similar kind of high culture prestige,
the
early 2000s were a feverish period of hydro-organon construction.
The
first to be built, after the Senritsu,
was
the smaller, but in many ways more elegant mission outside of San Francisco,
followed
by the Imperatore in the Gulf of Naples,
in
honor of the legendary hydro-organon Tiberius was supposed to have
off
of Villa Jovis.
Hydro
-organons were built in New York, Marseille, Seattle, Dubrovnik, Edinburgh, Copenhagen.
It
became a symbol of status,
a
way of establishing a city's cultural, cosmopolitan bona fides.
New
pieces of music were written with the hydro-organon in mind, which dovetailed nicely with the development of popular electronic drone music.
The
Senritsu was even featured during a chase scene in a Bond film,
the
air bubbles from its pipes providing a screen for Bond's escape
after
a particularly tense encounter with the agents of a Russian cartel. Construction tapered off after the recession of 2008, however.
It
was hard to justify spending money on something so frivolous to a population being asked to surrender its retirement for the sake of austerity.
There
was also the matter of the aging ideological combatants in the theoretical world of hydro-organonology,
who
could drum up little sympathy for the cultural wars of the 90s
among
the new generation of hydro-organologists,
all
of whom were much more interested in critiquing the barriers facing upcoming women hydro-organonists and hydro-organonists of color in accessing the resources needed to enter the highly competitive world of professional hydro-organonics
than
in designing newer, larger, and more creative hydro-organons.
And
so it came as exciting, though somewhat puzzling news,
when
the Chibukdo project announced it would build the world's largest hydro-organon in Halifax harbor.
Rumor
had it that the same family of oil billionaires who had controlled most of the industry on the east coast
are
behind the venture,
but
it has so far proved impossible to either confirm or deny this,
and
hydro-organonologists have never been particularly zealous about following the money trail behind their favorite projects.
The
bar below Prince and Argyle was not the kind I would have walked into if I weren't traveling on an expense account. Everything in it was old,
except
for the servers, who were very young.
I
took off my jacket
and
sat at the bar and ordered a dark beer.
I
asked the bartender what she thought of the organ.
She
looked at me as though she weren't sure what I was talking about.
The
organ being built in the harbor, I said.
She
told me she thought organs were supposed to be in churches.
When
I told her they didn't need to be, she shrugged. Someone else sat down at the bar and I was left alone with my beer.
What
am I doing here? I wondered.
And
then I thought of the years I had spent sending out pitches, covering concerts, doing profiles,
writing
about who was getting funding, what pieces were being played in the upcoming season,
which
alcoholic European maestro had landed somewhere uncritically provincial to drink away the last third of his career.
They
were all very happy, and I was miserable.
I
ended up on the roof,
where
I was joined by my girlfriend and Andrew, one of the first violists.
They
had not realized I was there.
This
was, I later learned, shortly after they had started sleeping together.
He'd
just returned from Venice,
where
Antonio Carpaccio was building his Serenissima off the Lido de Venezia.
He
told us all about it.
He'd
gone to the Milan Conservatory with one of Carpaccio's assistants,
and
when they reconnected over dinner after a concert Andrew had played in at the Teatro Fundamenta Nueve,
the
assistant had invited him to dive down to the build site the next day. Andrew said it was one of the most beautiful things he'd ever seen.
I
wasn't sure what to think.
My
tastes were more conservative then,
but
I never forgot the picture he showed me of the great pipes glowing softly in the blue light of the Adriatic.
Two
months later, the cellist asked me to move out.
Her
career was taking off, and she was in love with Andrew,
and
by then I had given up on playing music.
I
only wanted to write about it.
It
was purer, somehow.
A
photograph of blue sunlight playing over a set of stainless steel pipes eight fathoms down had convinced me of that.
Of
all the arts, the beauty of music is the most unreliable.
One
can only experience it in time, and time is the enemy of art.
The
idea of music, however,
is
eternal.
I
thought about all of this in a bar below Argyle Street
as
I drank dark beer and watched the young servers bring minimalistic plates of seafood to the old and wealthy.
I
wondered what the men in cravats thought of the hydra working on,
but
the bartender didn't say anything more about it,
and
neither did I.
The
next morning, I woke up hungover
at
825,
rain
on the window.
I
was supposed to be meeting a man named John Phillips at a cafe on the other side of the harbor at 930.
I
didn't know what schedule the ferries ran on
or
whether I should take the bus.
The
hotel's complimentary coffee tasted like tree bark.
The
shower never got warmer than tepid.
I
hadn't unpacked my clothes. I hadn't written my questions.
I
only had a general idea of what I wanted to know.
Why
build a hydroorganon in Halifax?
Why
build a hydroorganon now?
Why
make it the largest in the world? What was there to prove?
The
whole thing felt meaningless and absurd.
When
I got to the cafe, I was 15 minutes late and soaking wet.
Phillips
had already had a coffee and a croissant.
The
cafe was famous for its croissants, he explained.
I
really had to have one. It was part of the experience.
They
were the best croissants in the Maritimes.
I
told him I'd eaten at my hotel.
The
water from my jacket dripped onto the floor below me.
Phillips
was the kind of Easterner who, despite never having really spent any time on a boat or outside of the city,
feels
that being born in a certain proximity to the
sea,
entitles him to pronouncements on nautical life.
He
spoke about the beauty of the Atlantic, the tragedy of the fishery, the humble nobility of fishermen, all that lost salt gift of blood shit.
He
seemed more comfortable when speaking about the importance of Nova Scotia,
the
vibrant cultural scene. Halifax, he told me, was a world city. Haligonians had music in the ocean in their blood.
He
himself was a great music lover. Listened to music all the time.
Had
I heard of Joel Plaskett? Great local musician. And did I know he lived just up the way? Also a great city for fiddle music, Halifax. If I couldn't get to a genuine East Coast kitchen party, I should check out one of the excellent bars along Argyle Street.
Had
I heard about the first rate nightlife in Halifax.
People
who visited Halifax loved to hear that wonderful, authentic, totally unique, world famous East Coast fiddle music played at open mic nights.
People
from all over the world came.
Nova
Scotia was like no other place on Earth,
which
is why it was the perfect place to build the largest organ, sorry, yes, hydro-organon, the world had ever seen.
He
was proud to represent the provincial government's interest in the project. Music in the ocean. You won't find two more authentically Nova Scotia things in all your born days. Something about the way he said this made me wonder if he used phrases like, all your born days, when talking to people who actually lived here.
But
what I asked was whether or not he had any qualms about the fact the organ was going to be under water.
Were
Haligonians, with their famous love of music, going to be diving down to witness the dull heaving of the pipes, the careful finger work of an organist they were barely able to hear? Philip simply chuckled.
Had
I heard of the legendary City Bank Colossus by the base of the Statue of Liberty?
Well,
the Chibucto had fully double the footage of pipes, three times the power,
and
people thought there was nothing happening in Halifax.
He
refused to answer any of my questions about where the money was coming from.
It's
a private-public partnership, he said.
All
the necessary paperwork has been filed with the province and the Halifax Regional Municipality,
and
I'm sure if you file a request for information they'll be happy to let you access it.
He
asked whether I would have a chance to meet the architect while I was in town.
I
told him we'd be speaking later that afternoon. She'd arranged for me to take a tour of the worksite.
He
laughed professionally.
You're
a lucky man, seeing our beauty without our clothes on.
I
assumed he meant the organ.
This
is going to go down in history. Large of its kind in the world. Make sure you mention that in your article.
I
told him I would.
He
said it had been a pleasure.
Phillips
walked out of the cafe, pinstripe suit creased around the oval of his shoulders, sweat glistening on the skin of his neck folding over his collar.
His
shoes were carefully polished,
hair
arranged to minimize the growing bald spot on the crown.
I
wondered what he thought had happened during our conversation.
The
weather cleared up around noon,
and
the sun came out.
The
entire city seemed different.
I
was standing on the pier, going through my notes, when I saw a tall, broad-shouldered woman staring at me from a nearby bench.
She
had short gray hair, and the kind of advanced fiber shirt people who go hiking in the Himalayas wear.
She
was, I realized, Rebecca Schumacher, chief architect at the Chibukdo project.
And
she had recognized me before I recognized her.
You
must be the journalist, she said when I caught her eye. Yes.
You're
early.
It's
a nice day.
Above
the surface, yes,
but
the rain means more silt in the harbor.
We
can still go down this afternoon if you want to, but I'd advise waiting until tomorrow.
I
leave tomorrow night.
We
can do it in the morning.
The
weather is supposed to hold overnight.
Are
you still free for an interview?
Yes, but
I'd prefer not to speak in public.
You
understand that I need something from you on the record.
Of
course.
I
just don't like speaking in public. Schumacher got up from the bench and started to walk away.
Not
knowing what else to do,
I
followed her. Rebecca Schumacher.
I'd
spent weeks before arriving in Halifax trying to trace her digital outline, but to little avail.
It
wasn't only that she had zero social media presence and no web page, already unusual for a musician given their tendency to err on the side of providing more personal information rather than less.
And
yet, even after employing some of the more arcane journalistic tricks for digging up buried identities,
I'd
only been able to put together a cursory biographical sketch.
Born
in London in 1959 to a Jewish family from Königsberg, Schumacher was accepted to study piano at the Royal College in 1976.
She
graduated with honors, having switched her specialty to organ,
and
seems to have left London in 1980 following a brief stint at St. Martin in the Fields.
No
record exists of where she went,
or
what she spent the next six years doing, which in and of itself is quite astonishing for some of her accomplishments. Stranger still is the fact that when she resurfaced, it was in Tokyo, playing organ at an Episcopal church.
She
met Saito there at some point in the late eighties,
and
even played a series of concerts with him.
He
was known to have been working on his plans for Senritsu at that time,
but
it is not clear whether she was formally involved in the project.
She
does appear in a very peripheral way in some of the documentaries on the construction of the hydroorganon,
and
in photographs taken during that time.
A
tall woman, short black hair, smoking a cigarette outside Saito's cabin,
standing
in the background while Saito pours over the blueprints,
sitting
in the boat with two of his assistants eating a sandwich.
It's
even likely she played Senritsu at some point,
though
it is not clear how close she was to Saito,
if
indeed they had any sort of personal relationship at all.
She
returned to the West before his death
to
study marine engineering at MIT,
but
did not complete a degree.
In
1998, she came to the attention of academic musicologists after publishing her remarkable first monograph, On the Ontology of Sound, Notes Toward a Hydroorganonology.
Noted
for its lucid prose, On the Ontology of Sound was the first work of hydroorganonology to really wrestle with the implications of what was by then known as the sound question,
in
other words,
how
to understand the radically different experiences audience members had during concerts on the hydroorganon.
Her
monograph made the novel argument that, regardless of whether one heard or did not hear the music,
the
hydroorganon provided a purer way of listening to, and therefore
a
better way of understanding,
the
works for organ by Johann Sebastian Bach and Dietrich Buxtehude.
It
was, however, savaged by some of her more militant peers,
who
saw in it a conservative and even theological sort of essentialism,
and
few scholars have picked up her line of reasoning in the years since.
In
2000,
Schumacher
landed a job as organist and choirmaster at St. Augustine's in New York City,
where
she remained for seven years.
During
this time, she published a few minor pieces on hydroorganonology,
including
a controversially negative review of the Citibank Colossus,
then
under construction mere kilometers away from Schumacher's home on the Lower East Side.
In
2008, she took a sabbatical and did not return.
She
was credited with having worked alongside Carpaccio on the Serenissima in an advisory capacity from 2007 to 2008,
and,
following its unveiling, was one of several resident hydroorganonists, a post she returned to intermittently over the next few years.
In
2014,
the
Jabucto Project announced that, following a rigorous international hiring process, she had been chosen to design and execute the building
of
the largest hydroorganon in the world in Halifax Harbor.
It
had been much harder to discover anything about Schumacher's personal life.
Even
establishing her connections to other prominent organists and hydroorganonists had been difficult.
Those
she had worked with spoke of her in tones of awe,
but
never warmth.
None
of the team who worked with Saito responded to my requests for information. Not surprising, given the language barrier, the time elapsed,
and
the understandable wariness with which they treat media requests, given how his story has been sensationalized over the years.
And
I had been unable to establish whether or not Carpaccio sought her out to work with him on the Serenissima,
or
what exactly she had advised him on.
Were
they perhaps friends? Impossible to know. Carpaccio, generally eloquacious in interviews, was coy when asked about Schumacher.
She
was an artist whose work he respected, which is the kind of comment one public figure makes about another
when
they either have nothing to say,
or
far too much.
She
was, so far as I was able to ascertain, unmarried.
No
children.
All
of this left me with a notebook full of questions.
She
brought me back to her car and drove us out of the city towards the end of the peninsula,
pulled
over halfway to Sombro Head near a conservation area.
I
like walking here,
she
said.
You
can interview me while we walk.
As
we made our way down a path towards the ocean,
I
asked her what had drawn her to hydro-organology in the first place.
I
like the ocean,
and
I like the organ.
Next
question.
Why
did you apply to work on the Chibucto?
I
needed a job.
I
was tired of playing organs and hydro-organons for audiences who didn't
or
couldn't understand what they were hearing.
What
is your vision for the Chibucto?
I'd
like it to work,
and
I'd like it to play nicely.
Anything
else?
I'd
like it to be played only by people who understand what they're doing.
This
is the third hydro-organon you've worked on.
How
do you see your vision being different from Carpaccio's, say, or Saito's?
Kenji
made Senritsu because he believed in God. Carpaccio made Serenissima because he believed in himself.
But
I only believe in the ocean. I'm not sure what that means.
When
one is in the ocean,
there
is always the possibility one is a few moments from death.
It
strips away one's illusions.
Would
it be fair to describe you as a nihilist, Miss Schumacher?
No. As
I said,
I
believe in the ocean.
I
subscribe to an ocean-based metaphysics.
But
no one who has not spent as much time in the ocean as I
would
understand it.
And
I'm sure that isn't what your magazine wants to know either.
What
was your relationship with Kenji Saito?
We
were lovers.
Really? No. We
were walking across the smooth rock of the shoreline. Schumacher was staring out at the Atlantic.
There
was no sign of the city we had so recently left.
No
houses.
Just
the gray waves of the harbor.
She
stopped walking and removed her hands from her pockets,
let
the strong east wind raise her arms as if they were aerofoils.
I
think she wanted me to be quiet, share the moment with her.
So
I put my notebook in my breast pocket
and
let the wind blow cold over me.
We
liked to talk about music,
she
said eventually,
and
about the ocean.
I
thought what he was doing was important,
but
misguided.
Because
he believed that God had created the ocean, and he believed that putting an organ in the ocean would bring him closer to God.
I
suppose you could say it did, if you have a certain sense of humor.
What
Kenji didn't understand was that the ocean is God,
and
the Hydra Organon is our means of worship.
In
your monograph, you say that only by playing the great Baroque masterpieces underwater
can
we grasp their full symmetry and order,
and
the terror this order should inspire in us.
I
wrote that a long time ago.
You've
changed your mind then?
My
mind has been changed by the ocean. What do you mean?
I
wouldn't say that now.
I
would say that once you have heard the Leipzig corrals played on the Hydra Organon
as
dusk is approaching and the water is growing dark around you,
you
understand that to be terrified of the ocean is to be terrified of death.
And
to be terrified of death
is
to be terrified of symmetry and order,
to
be terrified of the world,
to
be terrified of art.
And
what's the sense in that?
Do
you ever worry that hydro-organology is a dying art?
That
years from now, divers will swim around their wreckage the way they now visit drowned cities.
I'm
going to answer your question because you've come all the way to this provincial city to ask it,
but
I will not answer it on the record
for
my Hydra Organon is not yet finished.
I
would ask you not to mention it in your article.
I
understand.
The
greatest mistake Kenji made
was
telling the world about Senritsu.
It
was his act of hubris.
Just
as the Hydra Organon allows us to fully experience the reality of sound,
playing
the Hydra Organon for no one but the ocean allows us to truly understand the ultimate truth above all human art. Nothing degrades a Hydra Organon so much as the human eye.
The
Hydra Organon should bring us closer to the ocean itself,
and
the closer we are to the ocean,
the
further we are from humanity.
The
day no one will pay to dive into the ocean to hear me play the Chibucto
is
the day the construction will have finished,
and
the Hydra Organon can begin its true work.
Do
you plan to stay here, then, once the project is over?
I
think so.
The
ocean is everywhere, but here it feels very present,
and
there are so few people.
Perhaps
you will understand when we go down to see it tomorrow.
Perhaps
not.
With
that, Schumacher began walking back to the car.
Our
interview was over. Perhaps I would understand.
Two
days later the words still bothered me, sitting silently in my Pullman seat as the train cut its way north.
Had
I understood anything I'd seen or heard in my short time in that city?
What,
indeed, might it mean for me to have understood?
I
flipped through the pages of my notebook and thought about what I would tell my editor.
There
was a story here.
There
must be a story.
There
is always a story,
even
if that story is that there is no story. Outside my window the thick brush seemed endless.
From
time to time the dark monotony was punctured by the silver gleam of water slipping over river stones in moonlight,
and
all I wanted was to have someone tell me
this
was only an illusion of light and shadow.
But
I knew I would never believe someone who told me that again.
When
I met Schumacher on the dock on the morning of our dive, she said nothing of our conversation the previous day.
In
her silence I read no discomfort. Only the certainty of a person who speaks only when she wants to speak.
We
boarded the boat.
She
introduced me to the pilot, a small man in McLaughlin who only opened his mouth to spit over the gunwale. Schumacher gestured for me to change into the diving suit she had brought.
When
I was ready,
she
told me what I needed to know in case of an emergency.
When
the boat reached the harbour mouth, where the water was cleaner,
she
tapped me on the shoulder.
When
she slipped off the side of the boat, I followed her into the ocean.
It
was a sunny day, and the rays pierced the waves.
Below
us the seabed sloped into darkness.
We
swam for a long time. Schumacher seemed always to know where we were.
At
certain points she would point out things of particular interest—wrecked fishing boats or an old mine.
And
then we rounded an outcrop and I could see, glinting in the distance,
a
series of massive pipes rising from a rocky ledge.
As
we drew closer, I became aware of the awesome scale on which the complex had been built.
For
complex is the only word that now occurs to me to describe the massed ranks of pipes,
the
flights in descending order of length stretching like great silver wings on either side of the keyboard,
the
organist bench, an oblong of stone and steel
that
seemed impossibly small to control such a monstrous creation, a vast palace of metal.
The
ledge onto which it was built stood at a juncture where the gentle slope of rock and sand falling away to the ocean floor
met
the base of the headland rising sharply towards the surface.
Out
towards the eastern depths,
one
could make out the fish, the kelp,
the
chains of seaweed glowing in the heavy aqueous light of the sun.
The
rock of the headland seemed to encircle the hydroorganon's towering mass,
a
movement of enclosure reflected in the flights of pipes that curved gently out from the keyboard itself.
It
seemed almost natural, snug against the rock. Schumacher swam ahead of me,
and
when she reached the base of the organ, I noticed a bank of levers below the hydroorganonist's seat.
She
slid two of them into place,
and
the hydroorganon shuddered to life with a low mechanical hum.
She
gestured for me to join her.
While
she took her seat, I hovered in the water above,
watching
her remove the flippers from her feet so she could manipulate the pedals.
The
keyboard had a full five manuals.
She
looked up at me and raised her shoulders, as if asking whether I was ready.
I
nodded.
She
slid a few stops out,
placed
her hands over the first and fourth manual.
Then
she played a chord.
There
was a rush of air from the pipes, and a jet of bubbles was expelled.
Then
the force of the air pushed me backwards from the instrument,
and
I was left floating several meters in front of the massive tenor pipes,
watching
the air stream from up towards the surface.
There
was a low rumble, one that grew and slackened in intensity.
It
was joined by a quavering and a quaking as Schumacher opened more stops.
But
that was it.
I
watched as her fingers danced between manuals, and I could see the machinery vibrating,
the
air pouring up toward the surface as new pipes opened.
I
could see the patterns in the bubbles,
and
sense the hydroorganon's energetic pulse.
But
I could hear very little. Schumacher played and played,
and
as I became accustomed to the instrument's power, I began to notice the visual pattern of pipes opening and closing,
the
fountains of air developing a kind of rhythm
as
they exploded and were contained.
As
I swam about, I became aware of new and more impressive elements of the mechanism.
But
when I closed my eyes,
there
was only the rumble
and
the hum.
What
had it been like for those who heard a melody, I wondered?
What
was it like for Schumacher, who remained at the bench, fingers flying over the keyboard,
feet
pumping the massive pedals?
What
must it have been like for Saito, during the lonely nights in which she played to the ocean and god?
After
what seemed like hours, Schumacher ended her performance with a final flourish,
and
I could see her shoulders shaking
as
she rested her hands beside her on the bench, heaving as if she were in the grip of a strong emotion,
as
if she were crying, perhaps,
or
laughing.
The
sunlight played across the silver of the pipes,
and
the green of the vegetation and the brown of the stone,
and
fish began swimming back towards the hydroorganon, nosing about at the pipes, sliding silently, effortlessly between the gaps.
And
to the east,
the
ocean grew darker and darker, until finally it defied comprehension.
The
ocean
grew up
and
the
ocean
grew up and
the
ocean grew up and the ocean grew up and the ocean
grew up.
Merci.